Mitski returns with melodic message of love after brief musical hiatus

Mitski returned to the ears and hearts of all her fans through her latest album, The Land is Inhospitable and So Are We on September 15. The name of this seventh studio album would seem to indicate that Mitski is taking her music in a new direction that fans haven’t previously experienced. She certainly takes the trip in style, as she is accompanied by a 17-person choir and an orchestra, arranged and conducted by Drew Erickson.  

Mitski dove into the music industry in 2012 with her debut album Lush. She went on to produce four more albums before “quitting” music. This news devastated fans who believed that this was a permanent end to her career. After a year off the radar, Mitski surprised fans with the leading single for Laurel Hell,“Working for the Knife.” Many fans connect this song with her absence in the industry. After the conclusion of the Laurel Hell tour, Mitski hinted at another break in music. Although she is a passionate songwriter, Mitski believes being in the public eye goes against her nature, thus explaining why she goes on hiatus so frequently. Fans were unsure of what to expect of Mitski in the future, which left them ecstatic when The Land is Inhospitable and So Are We was announced. 

This album shows a completely new perspective to Mitski’s music. It’s even been described as her “most American album” in many accounts. Inhospitable is no different from Mitski’s previous albums, in that it showcases a wide range of themes throughout the album from loneliness and self-deprecation, to love, hope, and romance. 

The album was announced via Mitski’s newsletter, which included the name of the album and its leading single “Bug Like an Angel,” which came out later in that same week. “Bug Like an Angel” was able to set the tone for what was later to come on the album. Weeks later, the next set of singles, “Star” and “Heaven,” were released over BBC Radio 1. When asked about the significance of releasing these songs together on the same day, Mitski talked about how they show differing sides of the album from each other and “Bug Like an Angel.”

Before the release of The Land is Inhospitable and So Are We, Mitski previewed the album with a double feature taking place in only a few theaters throughout the United States, London, and Australia, with a final showing in Tokyo, Japan a week later. There were also listening parties in record stores throughout the world before the release of the album. These events were a unique way for fans to connect with each other while also getting to listen to the album before its official release date.

Inhospitable was highly anticipated by fans and it did not disappoint. Many fans described it as Mitski’s “most relatable album.” The album’s nothing short of meaningful, which Mitski makes clear through her reasoning behind writing it.

In a live stream she commented, “The best thing I ever did in my life was to love people,” she said. “I wish I could leave behind all the love I have, after I die, so that I can shine all this goodness, all this good love that I’ve created onto other people.” Mitski reinforces her purpose of this album with that statement.

The album opens with the leading single, “Bug Like an Angel.” This song presents themes of self-destruction and substance abuse before diving into “Buffalo Replaced,” which explores hope, identity, and isolation. 

“Heaven” is a poetic and romantic song. The orchestra adds to the cinematic and classically romantic vibe of the song. “I Don’t Like My Mind” begins abruptly after “Heaven,” interrupting the sweet and romantic mood and replacing it with self-doubt and regret.

“The Deal” offers an intense and dramatic song that includes themes of desperation and longing while “When Memories Snow” is another noteworthy title that expresses dealing with unpleasant memories and emotions. 

“My Love is Mine All Mine” is a beautiful song with many meaningful lyrics. Mitski describes the idea that nothing she has is permanent except her love, which is why she believes that to love is the best thing she has ever done. 

“The Frost” is almost melancholic in the way it describes isolation and loneliness. “Star” keeps the melancholic mood while switching to describe a love story. “I’m Your Man” explores themes of betrayal and self-doubt through a cynical tone. 

The album closes with “I Love Me After You,” which showcases the idea of self care and loving yourself even after the ending of a relationship. This song is more optimistic than some of the previous songs, closing the album on a hopeful note.

Mitski is currently on her Amateur Mistakes Tour. The tour only has a handful of shows throughout North America, the UK, and Europe, all playing in smaller venues. Given the rawness of the newer tracks, it only makes sense for Mitski to give this tour a more intimate feel in contrast to the typical concert experience. 

Ultimately, The Land is Inhospitable and So Are We is one of Mitski’s best albums. From the dramatic instrumentals to the meaningful lyrics, Mitski tells poignant stories through her music, all while promoting her theme of love.

Grade: A-

by Genna Blustin

Published on October 2 2023

Oshkosh West Index volume 120 issue I